Should you prioritize buying a house before retirement planning?

There is a popular opinion around home-buying that the earlier the better. Here is a quote from the incredible creator behind GeltGuide, Eli Fried:

For a frum family, a house is a very important financial need. Our families grow quickly and because we need specific neighborhoods, the prices rise drastically as well. You need to buy a bigger place earlier, when you can still afford it. Otherwise, you might end up outgrowing your small place, not be able to buy a bigger one because the price of the size you need is just so high.

Eli Fried

While I understand Eli’s point about the immediate need for larger homes in specific neighborhoods due to our community’s unique requirements, my concern lies in the long-term financial implications of this approach. Prioritizing a house purchase – especially one that might stretch a family’s budget – without factoring in retirement planning can create significant financial challenges down the line.

Eli’s suggestion does not advocate buying a house beyond one’s means. However, determining what is truly financially feasible is challenging without a comprehensive financial plan that includes retirement savings. Without this plan, it’s difficult to ascertain the long-term impact of a large mortgage on future financial stability, including the ability to save for retirement.

When a family commits to a mortgage for a large house, they are essentially locking in a significant portion of their future income towards housing costs. This commitment can make it challenging to allocate funds towards retirement savings later. It’s important to remember that once you have a mortgage, property taxes, maintenance costs, and possibly higher utility bills, your budget may not have the flexibility it once did to start allocating funds towards retirement.

The key issue here is the concept of financial sequencing and budgeting. If retirement planning is not integrated into the initial budgeting process when considering a home purchase, it often becomes a secondary priority that is continually deferred. As time passes, the opportunity to benefit from compound interest in retirement accounts diminishes. This can lead to a situation where, despite owning a home, individuals find themselves financially unprepared for retirement, lacking sufficient funds to maintain their lifestyle or cover healthcare costs in their later years.

Moreover, this approach can inadvertently foster a mindset where short-term needs consistently overshadow long-term financial planning. It’s vital to balance the immediate need for suitable housing with the necessity of long-term financial security. This balance involves a careful and realistic assessment of what one can afford in terms of housing without jeopardizing the ability to save for retirement.

It’s also vital to address the misconception of using a house as a primary means to fund retirement. While a home is a valuable asset, it shouldn’t be the main retirement strategy due to its lack of liquidity and the unpredictability of real estate markets. Unlike retirement accounts that can be liquidated gradually to provide a steady income, a home cannot be partially sold for retirement expenses. Additionally, the costs of maintaining a home, such as repairs and taxes, continue even in retirement, potentially reducing the actual amount available if the property is sold. Therefore, a balanced retirement strategy, including savings in retirement accounts and other investments, is essential for financial security in your later years.

In conclusion, while securing a home that meets a family’s needs is important, it should not come at the expense of retirement planning. A more sustainable approach would involve a balanced financial plan that accounts for both immediate housing needs and the crucial goal of building a retirement fund. This approach ensures financial stability and responsibility throughout one’s life, reducing the potential reliance on communal support in the future. This may result in a financial plan that has you buying a house now and starting to save for retirement later, but now you will have already properly planned for retirement before taking on that obligation.

Scroll to Top
× How can we help?